The Unofficial Royal Family Pages
Tuesday 5 October 2004 The Chrysanthemum Throne - Part IIIClick here for Part I As shown in Part I, one of the greatest beneficiaries of
the postwar changes was the Imperial Household Agency (IHA). Despite a
reduction in size, it was given almost complete control over the Imperial Family and a
huge budget to support its power. However, there seems to be little to no evidence
regarding the Agency itself, in such areas as its structure and membership, or its
attitude towards the Emperors loss of divinity. This extremely secretive agency
loves living in the shadows and reportedly responds to most direct questions regarding its
wards, the Imperial Family, or about itself with a cold, final no comment. Yet, one can glean a lot about the IHA by studying the
political institutions and events around it because a few things cant be hidden,
even by the IHA. For one thing, the IHA is closely intertwined with the political
powerhouse and ruling party of the past 50 years, the Liberal
Democratic Party (LDP), a party which has been described as being neither Liberal nor
Democratic. For another thing, the IHAs political attitudes can be inferred by
closely studying Japans political history since the end of WWII, since many of the
groups with which the IHA is involved, whether political or bureaucratic, have an almost
unbroken connection to the prewar, traditional conservatism. The years after the end of the war would have led
many a disinterested observer to think that Not so the Japanese government, a government that
was increasingly composed of conservative groups with ties to prewar institutions. For
example, in 1952, the Americans released 892 war criminals who had never made it to trial
and many of them returned to power in the government. Some of them rose swiftly to the
highest positions of power in the postwar government. Links to The government continued to treat the Emperor as
it had before the war, and for much of the same reasons too. Throughout the 1950s,
conservative groups tried repeatedly to amend the new Constitution to explicitly name the
Emperor as head of state. Their aim was not to revive the prewar or wartime
"emperor system." Neither was it to educate future generations in the old
imperial-nation view of history rooted in mythology. Rather, conservatives sought to
bolster the emperor's authority so they could use it for their own purposes.
(Herbert P. Bix, Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan, Harper Collins 2000, at pp. 654-655). Although they failed, their efforts were significant in showing the
institutional stubbornness that marks Attempts to change Clearly, the almost unreformed imperial system
made it hard for the old-school elite to shake traditional views, particularly when it
came to the role of the Emperor. For the same
reason, the government looked the other way while Emperor Hirohito made official visits to
Yasukuni, the main Shinto shrine which had been set up as a memorial to the
heroic war dead and was also the burial place for many individuals classified
as war criminals. The government upheld the prewar conservative ideology in
other ways too. For example, it ensured that all school textbooks had a whitewashed
version of
If the LDP seems a lot like the IHA in some ways, its because the two groups are very closely knit. The IHA deals almost daily with the government, a government which sets its budget, gives it orders regarding the Imperial Family, and makes the final decision about all imperial duties. In addition, the IHA is staffed by officials from various government agencies, as well as the civil service, both of which are drawn heavily from the LDP and, thus, infected by their ultraconservative values. Take, for example, the latest tutor to Princess
Aiko, Crown Prince Naruhitos only child and the future of the Chrysanthemum Throne.
Her fifth chamberlain or tutor has a background that is based purely in the
government and in various public ministries. While the tutor to a toddler is
unlikely to come from the highest government echelon, its equally unlikely that the
hidebound, conservative IHA and the ultra-nationalist LDP from which it takes its
orders would permit a progressive liberal to be in charge of someone as important
as Princess Aiko. The extent of the governments incredible
conservatism and of its archaic views regarding the Imperial Family is best demonstrated
by the situation involving the Yasukuni Shine. Yasukuni is a Shinto monument to
The IHA has been careful not to comment on the
Shrines interpretation of the Emperors role but it doesnt need to;
several Japanese prime ministers have been happy to do so in its place, both implicitly
and explicitly. Since 1945, numerous prime
ministers and cabinet officials have visited the Shrine, in an official capacity, and paid
their respects to the heroic war dead and the Emperor in whose name they
acted. Making matters worse, several of them have done so in an official capacity,
and just a day or so before August 15th, the date of The current Prime Minister, Junichiro Koizumi, has gone even further.
An ardent nationalist with a cult-like status, Koizumi is at the forefront of the
revisionist movement: he has called some of the Class-A war criminals buried at the
Yasukuni Shrine martyrs; he has
paid actual homage at the shrine in his official capacity as a government official; he has
refused to make any changes to the new school textbook giving the most inventive
explanation for Japans actions during WWII; and hes intent on amending the
Constitution to permit a military. In fact,
under his tenure, the Japanese parliament has begun a debate on revising the Church and
State portions of the Constitution, a debate which has clear implications for the Shinto
religion and, thus, for the Emperor with which its connected. Its doubtful that Koizumi seeks to return the
Emperor or the Imperial Family to their prewar status but it cannot be denied that any
change in the separation between religion and state will indirectly impact the
emperors role, especially under an ultra-conservative party intent on managing the
monarchy for its own political purposes. See, http://tinyurl.com/4nxbm. One may ask how the LDPs quasi-shogunate or
the nationalism shown by various Prime Ministers has to do with the IHA. Quite simply, the
IHA is tied at the hip to the LDP and, while Prime Ministers may come and go, the IHA
always stays the same. Its an
organization not subject to the vicissitudes of elections or public scrutiny. Yet, it
shares the same political traditions, systemic stubbornness towards changes, and
conservative ideology. The fact that the IHA is made up of officials who come from the LDP
and the LDP-filled Civil Service --- two groups with an almost unbroken tie to the prewar
political system and its accompanying political ideology --- merely strengthens the
Agencys ultra conservative approach towards the Imperial Family. Its unlikely that the IHA seeks to return
the Emperor to the position that he once held but its equally unlikely that it
favours a democratic, populist approach to the monarchy. There is probably no greater
abomination for the IHA, short of the monarchys complete absolution, than a
populist, bicycling monarchy like that of the Dutch. On second thought, a populist,
informal monarchy probably wouldnt be as horrific as the possibility of having the
previously divine monarchy treated like the British royal family. One can only imagine how
the IHA views the situation experienced by the While the IHA may not believe in a return to a
supposedly absolutist monarchy, it is still institutionally, politically and ideologically
incapable of ignoring the Imperial Familys traditional role. Its an organization which sees its wards
the Imperial Family as the living remnants of a history and tradition that While there have been eight empresses on the
Chrysanthemum Throne, they were essentially regents who did not pass power or rule to
their own descendents. These empresses were
either unwed or widowed and, upon their death, the throne reverted back to the next male
in the line of succession. Thus, the principle
of male succession remained intact. To the ultra royalists who make up the IHA, this
principle must continue to remain unbroken. Breaking that rule would be breaking Ironically, the Japanese public shares none of
these perspectives. In fact, the postwar
generation is at the opposite political and ideological spectrum from both the IHA and the
political elites. They have been for a long time. Things had changed dramatically from the
late 1940s when waves of screaming hordes greeted Emperor Hirohito on his purported
disaster tours. The younger generation viewed
Emperor Hirohito as a war criminal and had little interest in his successor. In fact, in
the early 1990s, the majority of the public couldnt tell you the name of the Crown
Prince (Naruhito) and they certainly didnt care about the new Emperor (Akihito).
Postwar events, cultural changes among the young and the IHAs attempts to maintain
the mystique of the Chrysanthemum Throne by keeping the Imperial Family aloof from the
public had only made the people indifferent to the monarchy.
Many were frankly hostile. The extreme conservativism of the political elite
was, thus, at a total variance from the pacifist, non-monarchial, modern approach of the
Japanese people themselves. Its within this context that the new Crown
Prince fell in love with the epitome of a modern, successful, professional woman. His
search for a suitable bride had taken more than seven long years, so long that -- in a
complete break from palace protocol -- his younger brother had gotten married ahead of
him. But the Crown Prince only wanted one woman and he was determined to wait for her. Ms.
Owada Masako was the daughter of a senior diplomat who had traveled the world with her
parents since she was a child. She went to kindergarten in Moscow, attended high school in
Boston, graduated from Harvard both Phi Beta Kappa (National Honours Society for
the top 10% of all students nationwide) and Magna Cum Laude, and then attended the
prestigious Balliol College, Oxford. Fluent in numerous languages, she joined the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs and was a career diplomat with a promising future when she met the
Crown Prince at a party. The Crown Prince fell in love there and then, and he refused to
consider anyone else. Masako, in contrast, was distinctly less enthused.
She knew very well the stresses and difficulties caused by marrying into the Imperial
Family. It was a well known, though little publicized, fact that Empress Michiko,
Naruhitos mother, had barely survived her induction into the Imperial Family. The Empress, the first commoner ever to marry into
the Imperial Family, had had such a difficult adjustment that shed had a nervous
breakdown and even lost her voice for 7 months. Its unclear if she couldnt
speak or if she simply didnt want to but, either way, one thing was clear: marriage
to the imperial heir was a Herculean task that could break even the strongest woman. Masakos qualms didnt stop the Crown
Prince. Its unclear how long Masako held out and how long he waited for her but some
say he refused to consider anyone else for as long as several years. Time after time, he
rejected the suitable brides paraded before him until, eventually, his parents asked him
what the problem was. He finally confessed his love for Masako. After much discussion, and
the Crown Princes insistence that his feelings would not change, he obtained his
parents permission to court her. That was just the first step. The Crown Prince
also had to convince the IHA officials that she was a suitable candidate, even though her
grandfather was a mere businessman. Then, he had to convince Masako herself. The latter proved to be the most difficult task.
Masako refused him three times but still he persisted. Finally, he said, I promise
to protect you with all my power as long as I live. Those must have been the magic
words because she agreed to marry him. In hindsight, those words may seem prophetic but I
think Masako knew exactly what she would be facing and what was necessary if she
and an Imperial marriage were to survive. Masako
was a child of the Establishment, with a father who was high up in the Diplomatic Corps. She grew up in a world and family which would have
given her much insight into There are other ways of looking at this famous
promise. One possibility is that Masako was influenced by such royal marriages as that
between Sarah Ferguson and Prince Andrew, The Duke of York. One school of thought argues
that the Another possibility is that Masako simply had no
more excuses to hold out once the Crown Prince made that oath. Some people have alleged
that she would have continued to refuse Prince Naruhitos offer but her father was
promised a significant promotion in his diplomatic postings if Masako accepted the
Princes proposal and she was sold into the marriage for the familys prestige.
According to these cynics, the fact that Masakos father received a more prestigious
diplomatic assignment almost immediately upon his daughters engagement and marriage
is proof positive that Masako was coerced or sold into marriage against her wishes. As a
romantic, I prefer to think that the marriage was based on real love, even if there was
some natural perturbation on Masakos side. After all, what modern, independent,
successful career woman would jump into the Imperial Family without even a seconds
hesitation, especially if they already knew of the IHA and its incredible power? Once the engagement was announced, there was a
huge swell in popular interest in the Imperial Family. Or, to be specific, in the future
Princess Masako. People who couldnt name
half the main members of the Imperial Family knew every detail of Masakos
upbringing. The country was delighted not so much because the recalcitrant Crown Prince
had finally chosen a bride but because Masako seemed to negate the image of the fusty,
boring, hidebound, conservative, aloof Japanese royals. In fact, Masako seemed the epitome
of a modern woman; her marriage, the ultimate love story; and the The couple
married on In this Japanese
royalist version, the wicked stepmother was alive and well in the form of the IHA, and
they werent going anywhere. To the contrary, they had certain expectations for Well explore that situation and the various issues involved in the succession crisis next week in Part IV. - |
Previous Pandora Box columns can be found in the archive
This page and its contents are �2005 Copyright by Geraldine Voost and may not be
reproduced without the authors permission. The "Pandora's Box" column is �2005 Copyright by the author who has kindly given permission for it to be displayed on this website.
This page was last updated on: Tuesday, 12-Oct-2004 10:10:53 CEST